I traveled to Tyler, TX this weekend for a tennis tournament for my daughter. Driving along highway 31 back to Austin on Sunday, I couldn’t help but notice a very large billboard with the phrase:
"Where’s the birth certificate?"
Of course, this is in reference to the group known as the "birthers", who seem to think that our president isn’t a naturalized citizen even though the evidence is clearly there that he was born in Hawaii. But then again, there’s no convincing some people. What surprises me though, is the tenacity of this "movement". It won’t go away. I think the basic issue is, there are just some people who will always ignore the evidence if it contradicts their world view. In this regard, the birthers are no different than the young earth creationists. No amount of logic or evidence will assuage them from their opinion. But the size of this group is surprising, numbering in the tens of thousands, maybe even the hundreds of thousands. And they are a very vocal group.
In the old days, before the Internet, this would have been a small subculture of people and would have had little chance of growing into the movement it is today. But in the world of the internet, there is a ready environment for any fringe idea to take root and grow, fed by a media that is in search of ratings over facts. The internet provides a bully pulpit for any subversive or subcultural view to be seen by millions. And with all the spectrum of opinions available among the billions of webpages, there is no need for anyone to view an alternative opinion to their own.
In fact, we all have our favorite websites, bookmarked in our browsers for easy access or fed to us in our feed readers. And more than likely they consist of those sites that agree with our opinions or that feed our political leanings. There’s no need to look at dissent or alternate opinions. No need to try to see things from the other side of the fence. In fact why should we? Those alternate opinions were written by individuals who have a bias, right? While the websites we like are written by those who are thoughtful and knowledgeable. Why would I waste my time on those other silly opinions? I already know they can’t be right.
And that’s the root of the problem. There’s no longer any room for rational discussion or talking about the actual merits of any issue. No concept of respecting the individual who might have a differing opinion. There’s only room for opinion that is skewed either left or right for consumption by the faithful. Our surfing habits only foster a reinforcement of our preconceived opinions. And this leads to a wider polarization of our society. Those on the left and those on the right, with no need for either side to try to understand the other, only the ability to despise what they stand for as we’re told how silly they must be to think like they do.
This narrowly focused view of the issues also allows for mis-information to be easily disseminated. If the media outlets have a ready audience that is already agreeable to their philosophy, sowing the seeds of mis-information is easy. They already know their audience is not very likely to fact check what they say. So we end up with the idea of "death panels" in the health care reform bill, or calls of "socialism".
In this regard, if we’re not careful to understand where our information is coming from and to not get our information from a variety of sources, we could all become members of the lunatic fringe.